Notes
- narratives give meaning to events and circumstances
- narrative framing gives meaning to identity
- narratives do not merely reflect personality, but are a component of identity
- eg, a life story gives meaning to the events a person experienced, weaving them into a coherent whole; and can tell us who they’ll become or what happens next
- well-constructed narratives influence by triggering identity
- there are four components to a strategic narrative
- meaning
- identity
- content
- structure
- narratives provide meaning to a series of events by holding them together in a certain way
- narratives can trigger predictable behavior
- target audience analsysis is often focused on demographic data
- you need to understand the current identity of an audience to choose a narrative frame
- narrative can bond narrator to audience, making it difficult to counter regardless of facts
- this guide is weak on content; expected for manipulative spooks
- structure is the way content is relayed in a narrative
- structure and content can be culturally dependent
- one example is Aristotle in the West:
- harmonious state of affairs
- conflict
- resolution and catharsis
- narrative terrain is the ability to recognize foreign ones, composed of new stories, structures, and narratives (?)
- the “problem” the authors point to in Western narratives is only a “problem” when lying or manipulating; inner integration and consistency work when truth telling
- the authors seem to miss this critical fact: inner integration and consistency reflect a Western pursuit of enlightened truth, which their work is at odds with
- trying to say that narrratives do not reflect objective reality exemplifies this; underscored by saying narratives represent the interests of power
- this book tries to make grand claims about narratives that are partly untrue; the authors’ self narratives is leaking into their narrative about narratives
- the authors seem to be conflating their manipulative usage of narratives with the general topic; eg, narratives can allow for alternative narratives to co-exist
- audiences should feel that they’re recognizing a presentation of reality; not doing that makes a narrative fall flat
- an example is that narratives should reflect a familiar structure to the audience
- both content and structure should be familiar
Questions
- The four components of narratives are:
- meaning – the overall meaning that is given to the collection of facts
- identity – how the narrative relates to layers of identity
- content – facts and other inclusions within the narrative
- structure – the way that the narrative is composed
- (See definitions above.)
- Narratives which do not align with the (cultural) identity of the audience “fall flat” because the listener doesn’t view them as a reflection of reality.
- Liars and manipulators become transparent when failing to be internally consistent; not a real “problem”, but rather a frustration of the authors.